Sample deliverable · Signed-Case Tracking Review · Before · Agile Digital Agency

How a new client reaches the firm, and what each system catches

Entry path map from the first audit of a single-office workers' comp firm running Google Ads, CallRail and Lead Docket. It shows every route a prospect can take, which tool records it, and whether a signed case can be credited back to Google Ads. Built from one month of call and lead exports and the Google Ads account settings, before anything was changed.

Anonymised sample of the starting state. The firm's name, phone numbers, case values, campaign names, account IDs, client names, lead numbers and dates have been removed.

Entry paths and systems

Click ID survives to the signed case Works only if intake links the call Not trackable / data lost Wrong data created System step

Scenario by scenario

PathWhat gets capturedIntake system sourceSigned case reaches Google Ads?What we found
Ad click, web formForm passes click ID and UTM in hidden fields. GA4 logs the submission.Opportunity "Website Form", then lead with click IDYes via the automationSigned form leads uploaded correctly
Ad click, calls site numberCallRail pool number ties the call to the visitor's click ID, UTM and keyword. Recorded.Phone call record. Becomes a lead with tracking only if it is the initial call or gets associatedOnly if linkedSigned case lost: lead typed by hand, phone mistyped, call stayed unassociated
Taps call in the adGoogle counts "Calls from ads". Call lands on a dedicated CallRail number with click ID.Phone call record, same rules as aboveOnly if linkedSigned case uploaded where the call was linked
Organic, GBP site link, AI, directSame site and pool numbers, no click ID. CallRail labels it organic or referral.Call or form record without click IDCorrectly not AdsWorking as expected
Calls main lineNothing. The main office number is not on call tracking. Includes Google Business Profile calls and anyone with the number saved.Lead typed by hand, source is intake's guessNo, untrackableSigned case with no source trail at intake
Calls intake system numberStatic tracking number from the intake system: caller and time only. No duration, recording or click ID.Phone call record with no source detailNo37 calls in the audit month, placement of the number unknown
Referral, billboard, walk-inNothing automaticLead typed by hand, Marketing Source picked by intakeCorrectly not AdsWorking as expected
Office line calling a website numberCallRail attaches whichever web visitor holds that number at the timeUnassociated call tagged as a paid brand callFalse paid calls16 office-line calls in the audit month, 9 to website numbers

What Google Ads receives today

  • Calls from ads (Google, primary): every call from the ad's call button, including existing clients.
  • First-time phone call (CallRail import, primary) and repeat phone call (secondary).
  • Form submission (GA4, primary) and form capture (CallRail, secondary).
  • Signed case (offline conversion through a third-party automation, primary) at a token default value, far below the firm's average fee. No upload for several weeks.
  • No Google Ads tag on the site, so remarketing lists stay empty.
  • Bidding is manual, so these conversions shape reporting, not bids, today.

Fixes that close the gaps

  • Intake: create the lead from the call, or associate the call. Weekly check of unassociated calls.
  • Google Ads tag through Tag Manager on all pages.
  • Enhanced conversions for leads: rescues form leads that lose their click ID. Does not help phone-only leads.
  • CallRail: deal with office-line calls; fix the source mapping that labels paid pool calls as organic.
  • Automation: confirm what happens when a lead has no click ID, and set the case value.